News / After The Session

After The Session: Working with low self-esteem?

Wednesday 22nd July 2026

Understanding and Working With Low Self-Esteem in Voice Users, 21st July 2026

With Dr. Luke Aldridge-Wadden Clinical Psychologist (NHS & Independent Practice, BAPAM)

Key Takeaways & Core Concepts

  1. Defining Self-Esteem

Referencing the work of clinical psychologist Dr. Melanie Fennell, Dr. Aldridge-Wadden emphasized that self-esteem is fundamentally about the overall opinion we hold of ourselves, how we evaluate ourselves, and the value we attach to ourselves as whole human beings.

Unlike self-efficacy (the belief in one’s ability to perform a specific task), self-esteem refers to an unconditional, over-generalized judgment of one’s entire worth. In voice users—where performance and identity are deeply intertwined—fluctuations or chronic difficulties with self-esteem are remarkably common.

  1. The Cognitive Behavioral (CBT) Model of Low Self-Esteem

The session explored how low self-esteem develops and maintains itself through two core components:

  • Personal Adequacy: Deep-seated beliefs regarding whether one is fundamentally "good enough" or competent.
  • Social Concept: Beliefs about how others perceive one's worth (e.g., "People will see right through me").

When a critical incident occurs—such as a period of illness, a vocal injury, or an unexpected voice crack during a performance—it can activate negative core beliefs. This often leads to a cycle of hyper-vigilance, self-criticism, performance anxiety, and safety-seeking behaviors (such as overcompensating, hiding, or avoiding singing altogether).

Case Study Focus: "Emma"

To connect theory with real-world practice, Dr. Aldridge-Wadden walked through a hypothetical case study involving Emma, a 34-year-old teacher and keen church choir singer recovering from a bout of severe laryngitis.

Despite recovering, Emma experienced ongoing vocal fatigue and sporadic hoarseness. This physical shift triggered a cycle of low self-esteem, where she began discounting her abilities, over-personalizing minor incidents in choir rehearsals, and considering quitting singing entirely out of fear that others judged her as "no longer capable."

Practical Tools for Voice Practitioners

While deep-seated developmental trauma or core belief restructuring belongs in clinical therapy, voice teachers and coaches can implement "light-touch" psychological principles to help break maintaining cycles of low self-esteem in the studio:

  • Fostering Awareness: Helping students track and log their thoughts, physical sensations, and behavioral responses when vocal challenges arise during practice.
  • Theory A vs. Theory B: Guiding students to separate the automatic appraisal (Theory A: "Everyone in the choir thinks I sounded terrible and hates me") from an equally plausible alternative (Theory B: "I am reasonably worried about my vocal fatigue, and my worry is making me hyper-focus on others' reactions").
  • Behavioral Experiments: Collaboratively designing low-stakes "experiments" in lessons or rehearsals. For example, testing whether transparently stepping out for a 5-minute vocal rest actually results in judgment from peers—or if people simply carry on without paying negative attention.
  • Strength-Focused & Acceptance Approaches: Drawing on Solution-Focused, Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT), and Compassion-Focused frameworks to help students tolerate difficult emotional states rather than using distress as proof of personal inadequacy.

Recommended Reading & Resources

For those interested in exploring this topic further, Dr. Aldridge-Wadden highlighted several foundational texts:

  • Melanie Fennell – Overcoming Low Self-Esteem (Overcoming Series)
  • Joe Oliver et al. – The ACT Workbook for Perfectionism and Low Self-Esteem
  • Elisa Monti – Research on voice, emotion, and trauma.

Thank you to Dr. Luke Aldridge-Wadden for another enriching session, and to all the attendees who joined us live and engaged in the Q&A!


Recent Posts

After The Session

After The Session: A (Very) Brief Course in Linguistics! with Miranda Guettlein

Voice Study Centre
Wednesday 18th November 2026

A recap of our introductory linguistics course for voice teachers, speech practitioners, actors and dialect coaches, led by Miranda Guettlein, linguist, dialect coach and editor of the Voice and Speech Review.

Read More...
After The Session

After The Session: Neurodivergence and Critical Disability Theory with Dr David Cane

Voice Study Centre
Monday 9th November 2026

A recap of our session with Dr David Cane, Senior Lecturer on the Voice Study Centre MA in Voice Pedagogy, on disability and neurodivergence within the voice teaching studio. When we talk about disability and neurodivergence in voice teaching, the first thing that comes to mind is often a single question: what do I do if a disabled or neurodivergent student walks into my studio? In this session, Dr David Cane invited us to think much bigger. The teacher might be disabled or neurodivergent. So might a choir director or a colleague. The songs we teach may depict or use disability as a metaphor. Even the foundational texts of voice pedagogy carry assumptions about bodies and voices. This was a densely theoretical tour, and David was open about that. His argument was that the most important work is not a checklist of practical tips, but a rethink of what we believe teaching is for. Here are the main threads.

Read More...
After The Session

After The Session: The Vocal Health Challenges for Actors and Singers with Leda Scearce

Voice Study Centre
Wednesday 4th November 2026

A recap of our two-part course with Leda Scearce, singing voice specialist and speech-language pathologist at Duke Voice Care Center in North Carolina. Over two afternoons, Leda Scearce took our community on a deep dive into the voice as a high-performance instrument. A former professional opera singer who taught at several universities before retraining as a speech-language pathologist, Leda now works with singers and other performers who have voice injuries. Her message across both days was clear: singers and actors are vocal athletes, and voice teachers are on the front lines of their vocal health. Here are the highlights from both sessions. Please note that this is a summary of a teaching session, not medical advice. If you or a student have a voice concern, see a qualified voice specialist.

Read More...